The Maids' Story
"Reviewed" by Craxton (craxton@erols.com)
| Publisher: |
Himeya |
| Cost: |
$29.95US |
|
|
I'll be honest with you. There's a reason my byline for this "review" puts "Reviewed" in quotes. This is not a review. One must have finished a game to review it accurately. I have not finished The Maid's Story. Well, I've *finished* it, but due to a critical miscommunication, I didn't get a successful ending, and I disliked The MaidStory so strongly that I'm reluctant to go back through it. So this is, then, not a review. Instead, let's call 's it a highly restrained and (hopefully) intelligent rant.
First off, for chrissake,
Himeya, proofread your documentation! If the manual says night
lessons (read: sex) are not necessary, then they better not
be necessary. As is, two of my maids failed because I hadn't
taught them properly. Now, if The Maids' Story been fun to
play, that would perhaps not be a big problem. Alas, there
is more to this then just a single difficulty, and as the
revie... sorry, as the intelligent ranter, It is my job to
point these out. Here, therefore, is a list of reasons that
I reccomend you not play The Maids' Story:
1) It's shallow. The gameplay
is as follows: Every day, you make a schedule for each maid,
choosing from either five or six options for each of three
time periods: morning, afternoon, evening. Six is WAAAY too
few. Yes, True Love, which I loved, had just as many. They
were also not the central focus of the gameplay. Whereas here
they ARE, and it sucks. When the maids do these chores, they
both gain in skill, and improve the house's condition. Wheeee.
Oh, yeah, you can also check in on them, and either scold
them or encourage them. When night falls, it's time for lust-
you can give the girls praise or gifts for their hard work,
or teach them the maid's after-hours duties. And that's basically
all there is to this concept. Oh, yeah, occassionally people
stop by, and you must have the maids serve them. If they do
good, they'll give you some money for the house's petty cash
fund. You can also pimp out your maids, if so inclined. Yay.
2) It's repetitive. The bedroom
is the only place things vary to a significant extent. For
the rest of the game, which is to say most of the game, virtually
nothing changes. After a few hours of playing, you've basically
seen it all, and you still have 70 or so game days to get
through. Ugh. And even the bedroom is nothing to write home
about- You order different kinds of sex acts, getting the
same picture and usually the same text each time you choose
a particular act. (Also, for some reason, the game always
makes you start by removing the girl's panties. Even if you
want her to do a blowjob or a tit-fuck, you have to remove
the panties first. What, your character has to check to make
sure they're still women?)
3) It's slow. This is suppossedly
a micro-simulation game, somewhat like True Love or Princess
Maker. Now, True Love had it's stats on a 120-point scale,
with high atrophy. Princess Maker had a large number of stats,
most on an 800 or 1000 point scale. The Maid's Story has the
sex stat on a 100-point scale, not too bad, but all other
skills are only on a five-point scale. Why does this matter?
In the preceeding games, because there was such a large numerical
gap between cluelessnes and grand mastery, you could *see*
your progress moving by six and seven points per day, and
get a feel that you were actually doing something. But in
The Maids Story, because the numerical range is so small,
you can't see the effect your work is having, until someone
actually gains a level. The result is that you feel disinterested
and unimportant, whereas a sim is suppossed to be involving
and addictive. Furthermore, since there's no significant atrophy,
and no major restrictions on skill gain other then your maids'
stamina, the simulation aspect completely breaks down, favoring
repetetive min/maxing over specialization.
4) It's totally submission
stuff. Now, this is not necessarily a problem, depending on
your perspective, and it would seem to be an integral part
of the maid fetish. But still... there is NO option to be
nice in the bedroom. You propose a sex act, and if she doesn't
agree, you do it anyway. You're the boss, after all. With
guests it's the same- you can reject their carnal advances
on the maids, but there's no incentive to do so, and several
incentives NOT to- you'll get money, and the maids will gain
in their sex skill. What this means is, unless you're into
submission or maids, there's really no point in the sex. Furthermore,
you have to do EVERYTHING, including some stuff that is guarenteed
to turn some people off- if you want them to reach the max
level of skill.
5) It's badly translated.
Not the well-done but over-americanized translation of EVE
burst error, nor the shaky but perfectly comprehensible translation
of True Love, this is just... just horrid! "a bad friend of
mine"? "anti-bug spray"? "That is a big, heavy stone" (said
in regards to something that can't even be considered a stone)?
"Such a dude is no relative to me"? "make you not able to
stand"? "It is not bad by killing germs"? "Oh, pretty? Please
don't speak the truth."? Sheesh... A Winner is This One!
6) It's mosaic-censored. Okay,
this is just baffling. Translation companies, and Himeya in
particular, have always prided themselves on their ability
to remove the mosaics used in sex scenes by virtue of Japan's
censorship laws. They frequently advertise 100% Uncensored
images in their games. So why the hell would they NOT remove
the censorship from a game where the only scrap of value is
in the H-pics? The mind boggles...
And finally, the one, all-inclusive,
overriding reason to leave The Maid's Story on the shelf,
a rationale encompassing all it's many flaws and problems:
It's *BORING*. Add shallowness
to tedium to slow pace to niche sex appeal to major flaws
in the translation, and you've got one big yawnfest. I was
sick of it the second day, and haven't stopped being sick
of it. Worse games I have played, but none of them such incredibly
effective cures for insomnia.
Bottom Line: Spend your late
nights watching Gundam Wing instead. (Seriously. Watch Gundam
Wing, it rocks.)


|